Natural Gas Fireplace Inserts: What to Look For Before You Buy

A drafty wood fireplace that sits dark most of the winter is one of the most common things we hear about from homeowners. Natural gas fireplace inserts solve that problem without tearing out the fireplace you already have. The insert slides into your existing firebox, connects to your gas line, and vents through a sealed system up the old chimney. You get real flames at the push of a button and heat that actually stays in the room.

Choosing the right one takes a little homework, though. Size, heat output, media, and controls all vary from model to model. Here’s what our design team walks through with every customer before they pick a natural gas insert.

Why Homeowners Switch to a Natural Gas Insert

An open wood fireplace looks cozy, but it doesn’t heat well. TheEPA’s Burn Wise program puts it plainly: “Fireplaces are typically very inefficient heaters.” Much of the warm air in the room rides up the chimney along with the smoke.

A gas insert changes the whole equation:

  • Sealed combustion. Modern inserts use a direct vent system that pulls outside air in for the flame and sends exhaust out. Room air stays in the room.
  • Instant fire. No kindling, no ashes, no waiting. Press a button on the remote and the flame is on.
  • Steady, adjustable heat. You control the flame height and, on many models, the blower speed.
  • Easy upkeep. No ash to haul and no wood to stack.

Natural gas is also already in most homes. According to theU.S. Energy Information Administration, about 60% of U.S. homes use natural gas for space heating, water heating, cooking, or drying clothes. If your furnace or range already runs on it, a gas line to the fireplace is usually a short run.

Start With Your Firebox Size

The most important number in any natural gas fireplace insert decision is the size of your existing firebox. Inserts come in set widths, and each one needs a minimum opening to fit.

Every firebox has four measurements that matter:

  1. Front width of the opening
  2. Back width at the rear wall of the firebox
  3. Height of the opening
  4. Depth from the front of the opening to the back wall

Masonry fireboxes usually taper toward the back, so the back width matters just as much as the front. A firebox can look plenty wide from the living room and still be too narrow at the rear for a larger insert.

Our current Heat & Glo inserts come in widths from 25” to 35”. A decorative surround covers the gap between the insert and the edges of your opening, so the finished look is clean even when the insert is a bit smaller than the fireplace.

If your fireplace is small or shallow, oursmall fireplace insert guide covers the compact options in more detail.

Compare the Natural Gas Fireplace Inserts We Carry

Here’s how our core Heat & Glo natural gas fireplace inserts stack up. Heat input is listed in BTUs per hour.

Insert

Sizes

Heat Input

Interior / Media

Blower

Heat & Glo Escape

30”, 35”

36,000 to 40,000 BTU

FireBrick panels

Built in

Heat & Glo Supreme

25”, 30”, 35”

27,000 to 35,000 BTU

Logs (30”), glass or brick panels

Built in

Heat & Glo Cosmo

30”, 35”

28,000 to 30,000 BTU

Fire glass or river rock

Included

Heat & Glo Provident

30”, 35”

30,000 to 32,700 BTU

Ceramic glass front, brick panels

Optional

Heat & Glo Escape

The Escape is our go-to when heat is the top priority. Its FireBrick interior panels radiate warmth back into the room, and Heat & Glo says they deliver about 25% more radiant heat than other gas inserts. ClearVue anti-reflective glass keeps the flame easy to see.

Heat & Glo Supreme

The Supreme comes in three widths, which makes it one of the most flexible options for odd or smaller fireboxes. The 30” model offers birch logs, and interior panels come in reflective black glass, traditional brick, or gray herringbone brick.

Heat & Glo Cosmo

Want a modern look? The Cosmo trades logs for a bed of fire glass or river rock in colors like Amber, Cobalt Blue, Ebony, and Iced Fog, set against fluted or reflective black glass panels.

Heat & Glo Provident

The Provident offers a classic look with a ceramic glass front and a choice of three decorative firescreen colors. A blower is available as an add on if you want faster heat.

Browse the full lineup in ourgas insert collection.

Heat Output: How Much Do You Need?

Bigger isn’t always better. An insert that runs too hot for the room will make you turn it down constantly, while one that’s too small won’t take the chill off.

A few factors shape the right heat output:

  • Room size and ceiling height. Open floor plans and vaulted ceilings need more heat.
  • How you’ll use it. Some customers want the fireplace to carry a room through cold evenings. Others want ambiance with a little warmth.
  • Insulation and windows. Older homes with big windows lose heat faster.
  • Blower or no blower. A blower moves warm air into the room faster and farther. See whethera gas fireplace insert with blower makes sense for you.

When we size an insert, we look at all of these together rather than picking off a chart.

Features That Make Daily Use Easier

Today’s natural gas fireplace inserts do a lot more than the units from 20 years ago. These are the features our customers end up appreciating most.

Remote and App Control

Heat & Glo inserts use IntelliFire controls. Depending on the model, you can adjust flame height, fan speed, and accent lights from a touchscreen remote, a wall switch, or the IntelliFire app on your phone.

Battery Backup

Several models keep running during a power outage thanks to battery backup. In a Midwest winter storm, that’s a real comfort.

Safety Screens

Glass on any gas fireplace gets hot. Most inserts include a safety screen over the glass to help prevent accidental contact, a feature theU.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission strongly encourages for homes with young children.

Decorative Fronts and Surrounds

Fronts come in finishes like Black, Gun Metal, and New Bronze, and in styles from arched to clean and modern. Pair the front with anew mantel or surround and the whole fireplace looks brand new.

Natural Gas vs. Propane Fireplace Inserts

Most natural gas fireplace inserts we carry can also be set up for propane. The choice usually comes down to what’s available at your home.

Factor

Natural Gas

Propane

Fuel supply

Utility line to the home

Tank on the property

Best for

City and suburban homes

Rural homes off the gas main

Refills

None needed

Scheduled tank deliveries

Heat feel

Same flame and comfort

Same flame and comfort

If your home doesn’t have natural gas service, read our guide topropane fireplace inserts.

Safety and Indoor Air

A properly installed and maintained natural gas insert burns cleanly. Healthy gas appliances produce carbon dioxide and water vapor, and the sealed direct vent system sends that exhaust outside. Carbon monoxide only forms when combustion is incomplete, which is one reason a yearly tune up matters. We also recommend working carbon monoxide alarms on every level of the home, as theCPSC advises.

Regular care keeps the flame looking its best too. Ourgas fireplace tune up guide explains what our factory-trained technicians check each year.

Our Insert Buying Checklist

Before you pick a model, run through these questions:

  1. Do you have your firebox measurements (front width, back width, height, and depth)?
  2. Is your home on natural gas or propane?
  3. Do you want traditional logs or a modern glass or stone look?
  4. How much of the room do you want the insert to heat?
  5. Do you want a blower for faster, wider heat?
  6. Will you add a new mantel or surround at the same time?

Bring those answers to a showroom visit and we can narrow the choices in minutes.

Get the Right Natural Gas Insert for Your Fireplace

The best natural gas fireplace insert is the one that fits your firebox, heats your room the way you want, and matches your style. Measure carefully, think about how you’ll use the fire, and choose the features that fit your routine. Our factory-trained technicians handle the installation so the sealed vent system and gas connection are done right.

Ready to turn your drafty fireplace into a reliable source of heat?Contact Fireside or shop ournatural gas inserts to get started.

Frequently Asked Questions

What size natural gas fireplace insert do I need?

Measure your firebox front width, back width, height, and depth. Each insert lists a minimum opening, and a surround covers any gap between the insert and the edges of the fireplace.

Can a natural gas insert heat a whole room?

Yes. Our Heat & Glo inserts range from about 27,000 to 40,000 BTU of heat input, and a blower helps move warm air farther into the room.

Do natural gas fireplace inserts need a chimney?

Most inserts vent through a sealed direct vent kit that runs up the existing chimney. The system pulls in outside air for combustion and sends exhaust outside.

Can I convert a natural gas insert to propane?

Many models can be set up for propane with a conversion kit. Ask our team which models support propane before you buy.

Do gas fireplace inserts work during a power outage?

Several Heat & Glo inserts include battery backup, which keeps the fire running when the power goes out. The blower needs power, so it won’t run during an outage.